I’ve spent some time trying to figure out how to handle regular expression matching in Ioke. I really like how Ruby allows you to use literal regexps and an infix operator for matching. That’s really nice and I think it reads well. The problem with it is that as soon as you want to get access to the actual match result, not just a yes or no, you have two choices – either you use the ‘match’ method, instead of ‘=~’. The other solution is to use the semi-globals, like $1, or $&, etc. I’ve never liked the globals, so I try to avoid them – and I happen to think it’s good style to avoid them.

The problem is that then you can’t do the matching as well, and the code doesn’t read as well. I’ve tried to figure out how to solve this problem in Ioke, and I think I know what to do.

The solution is to introduce a magic variable – but it’s distinctly different from the Ruby globals. For one, it’s not a global variable. It’s only available inside the lexical context if an ‘if’ or ‘unless’ method. It’s also a lexical variable, meaning it can be captured by a closure. And finally, it’s a general solution to more things than the regular expression problem. The Lisp community has known about this for a long time. In Lisp the macro is generally called aif. But I decided to just integrate it with the if and unless methods.

What does it look like? Well, for matching something and extracting two values from it, you can do this:

str = "foo bar"
if(#/(.*?) (.*?)/ =~ str,
  "first  element: #{it[1]}" println
  "second element: #{it[2]}" println)

The interpolation syntax is the same as in Ruby.

The solution is simple. An if-method, or unless-method will always create a new lexical scope including a value for the variable ‘it’, that is the result of the condition. That means that you can do a really complex operation in the condition part of an if, and then use the result inside of that. In the case of regular expressions, the =~ invocation will return a MatchData-like object if the match succeeds. If it fails, it will return nil. The MatchData object is something that can be indexed with the [] method to get the groups.

The end result is that the it variable will be available where you want it, but not otherwise. Of course, this will incur a cost on every if/unless invocation. But following my hard line of doing things without regard for optimization, and only with regard for expressability, this seems like the right way to do it.

It’s still not totally good, because it’s magic. But it’s magic which solves a specific problem and makes some things much more natural to express. I’m not a 100% comfortable with it, but I’m pretty close. Your thoughts?

24 Comments | By Ola Bini | In: ioke | tags: ioke, magic it, regular expressions. | #